Baked Chili Rellenos – Easy, Healthy & Cheesy Recipe Guide

introduction

Looking for a lighter twist on a beloved Mexican comfort dish? Baked Chili Rellenos might just become your next obsession. Unlike the traditional fried version, this oven-baked beauty offers all the ooey-gooey cheesy goodness without the grease. Whether you’re craving a cozy family dinner, a vegetarian-friendly meal, or you’re just keen to avoid frying altogether—this dish checks all the boxes.

In this ultimate guide, we’ll cover everything from choosing the perfect peppers to flavor-packed stuffing options, and even how to make it work for keto, gluten-free, or dairy-sensitive diets. So, if you’re ready to fall in love with oven-baked chile rellenos, let’s jump right into it!

Table of Contents

Key Ingredients for the Best Baked Chili Rellenos

Creating the perfect baked chile relleno starts with choosing high-quality, flavorful ingredients. From the type of pepper to the cheese and seasoning, each component makes a big difference. Here’s a breakdown of what you’ll need—and how to pick the best of the best.

Choosing the Right Peppers for Baked Chili Rellenos

Anaheim vs Hatch vs Poblano: Which One Wins?

The backbone of any baked chili relleno is the pepper. Your choice sets the tone for the flavor, texture, and even the heat level of the dish.

Anaheim Peppers – Mild, slightly sweet, and large enough to stuff easily. A great choice for beginners.
Hatch Peppers – Earthier and spicier, these bring serious flavor to the table. They’re seasonal but worth seeking out.
Poblano Peppers – Rich, deep flavor with medium heat. They blacken beautifully and are a traditional favorite.

Tip: Always roast your peppers before stuffing. It brings out their natural sweetness and makes them easier to peel.

Need help deciding which pepper fits your taste buds best? Check out this Hatch vs Anaheim Peppers comparison for a full flavor face-off.

The Best Cheese for Baked Chile Relleno Recipes

The cheese stuffing is what gives this dish its signature melt-in-your-mouth magic. Go with a cheese that melts well, has good flavor, and complements the pepper’s kick.

Here are the top contenders:

Monterey Jack – Creamy and mild, melts like a dream.
Pepper Jack – Adds a gentle kick and spice blend—perfect if you want extra flavor.
Cheddar – Sharp and bold, ideal for a more robust flavor.
Colby or Colby Jack – A smooth, mellow option that plays well with others.

Want to geek out on melting cheeses? This guide to the best melting cheeses will up your cheese game instantly.

Optional Fillings and Add-Ins for More Flavor

While classic stuffed peppers usually feature just cheese, the beauty of oven chili rellenos lies in their flexibility. You can customize the filling to match your cravings, dietary needs, or what’s already in your fridge.

Here are some tasty options to mix in or swap:

Black beans or refried beans – Add fiber and texture
Grilled corn kernels – Sweet crunch
Ground chorizo or spiced chicken – For a protein-packed version
Shrimp – Adds elegance and coastal flavor
Sautéed onions and mushrooms – Boosts the umami factor

Spices and Seasonings That Bring It All Together

Even the best cheese and peppers fall flat without the right seasoning. Here’s what we recommend adding to your egg and flour mix:

Cumin – For warmth and depth
Black pepper – A sharp contrast to the cheese
Paprika or smoked paprika – Adds color and smoky aroma
Cayenne pepper – For a spicy kick (optional)
Salt – Always essential to balance the richness

Pro tip: For those watching carbs or going gluten-free, almond flour is an excellent substitute for regular flour. It won’t compromise flavor or texture, and it’s keto-friendly.

Step-by-Step Guide to Make Baked Chili Rellenos

Now that your ingredients are ready, it’s time to roll up your sleeves. Making baked chile rellenos might seem intimidating at first, but once you get the hang of it, it becomes a simple and satisfying routine. From roasting the peppers to pulling your cheesy creation out of the oven—this part breaks it all down for you.

How to Roast and Prepare the Peppers

First things first: char those peppers! Roasting your peppers brings out their natural sweetness and makes peeling off the tough skin a breeze. This step is crucial for smooth texture and deeper flavor.

Roasting Methods:

On a gas stove: Place the peppers directly over the flame. Turn with tongs until blackened on all sides.
Under a broiler: Set the peppers on a baking sheet and broil them, flipping every few minutes.
On a grill: Toss them on a medium flame and rotate until evenly charred.

Once charred:

Place peppers in a covered bowl or sealed plastic bag.
Let them steam for about 10–15 minutes. This loosens the skin.
Peel off the blackened skin under running water.
Gently slice down one side and remove seeds and membranes using your fingers or a spoon.

Note: If you’re using canned whole green chiles, you can skip this step—but fresh-roasted peppers truly elevate the flavor.

Preparing the Cheese and Filling the Peppers

With your peppers roasted and peeled, it’s time to stuff them with cheesy goodness—or a flavorful mix of cheese and extras like beans or shrimp.

Here’s how:

Slice your cheese into long strips—about 1 ounce per pepper.
If you’re adding extras like black beans or corn, mix them with the cheese in a small bowl.
Gently open each pepper and insert the filling. Be careful not to tear the pepper—it’s delicate!
Place each stuffed pepper seam-side up into a greased baking dish.

Making the Egg and Flour Mixture

Here comes the part that replaces the fried batter—an egg and flour custard that puffs up while baking and hugs the peppers in creamy warmth.

To make it:

Whisk together:
- 2 eggs
- ¾ cup milk (almond milk works too!)
- ¼ cup all-purpose or almond flour
- ½ tsp cumin
- ½ tsp salt
- ½ tsp black pepper

It’s okay if the batter has a few small lumps—it doesn’t need to be perfectly smooth. Pour this mixture evenly over the peppers in the baking dish.

Baking Your Chili Rellenos to Cheesy Perfection

You’re in the home stretch! Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). Sprinkle shredded cheddar, Colby Jack, or more Monterey Jack over the top of your stuffed peppers before baking.

Then:

Slide the dish into the oven, uncovered.
Bake for 35–40 minutes, or until the egg is set and the top is golden and bubbly.
Optional: Sprinkle with smoked paprika or cayenne pepper before serving if you want a little heat or smokiness.

Once done, let them rest for about 5 minutes. That’s it—your oven-baked chile rellenos are ready to be devoured!

Want to kick it up a notch with amazing sides and serving ideas? In Part 4, we’ll explore how to plate your Baked Chili Rellenos with the perfect pairings and variations for every dietary need.

Baked Chili Rellenos Variations You’ll Want to Try ASAP

Once you’ve mastered the basics of baked chili rellenos, it’s time to branch out! The beauty of this dish lies in its flexibility. Whether you’re feeding picky eaters, going low-carb, or just bored with the same-old cheese-stuffed version, these creative takes are going to keep things exciting—and seriously tasty.

Air Fryer Baked Chili Rellenos

Don’t want to heat up the whole kitchen? Air fryer chili rellenos are a game-changer. They still deliver that crispy outside and melty inside—without the oil, mess, or waiting on your oven to preheat.

How to make them:

Prepare and stuff your peppers just like the traditional baked version.
Preheat your air fryer to 370°F.
Spray the stuffed peppers lightly with oil spray.
Cook for 10–12 minutes, flipping once halfway through.

They’re quicker, crispier, and perfect for busy weeknights.

Baked Chile Relleno Casserole Style

If stuffing individual peppers feels like too much work—or if your peppers fall apart—go for a baked chile relleno casserole. It’s just as delicious and feeds a crowd effortlessly.

Layer it up like this:

Roasted, sliced peppers
Cheese (Monterey Jack, cheddar, etc.)
Optional extras: beans, corn, ground meat
Egg-flour batter poured over the top
More cheese and a sprinkle of cumin or paprika

Bake at 375°F for about 35–40 minutes. Slice like lasagna and serve with salsa, sour cream, or avocado slices.

This variation is perfect for potlucks, brunches, or just lazy Sundays when you want something cozy and hearty.

Stuffed Chicken with Chili Relleno Filling

Here’s a low-carb, high-protein twist that feels like something from a fancy restaurant: Chile Relleno Stuffed Chicken Breast. You get the same flavor profile, but in a protein-packed, grain-free format.

To make it:

Slice chicken breasts horizontally to create a pocket.
Stuff with roasted pepper strips and a combo of pepper jack or cheddar cheese.
Secure with toothpicks, season with cumin and paprika.
Bake at 375°F for about 25–30 minutes, until the chicken is cooked through.

If you’re watching carbs or skipping grains, this is your golden ticket. Want more ideas like this? You’ll love this creative spin on chili flavors from Eat This, Not That’s healthy Mexican cooking tips.

Vegetarian & Vegan Baked Chili Rellenos

Who says baked chile rellenos have to be all about cheese?

For vegetarians:

Add black beans, sweet potatoes, mushrooms, or quinoa to the filling.
Combine with reduced cheese for a lighter version.

For vegans:

Use dairy-free shredded cheese and swap the egg mixture for a blend of plant-based milk and chickpea flour or a flax egg substitute.
A dash of nutritional yeast and smoked paprika gives it that cheesy, umami-rich feel.

Keto-Friendly Chili Relleno Swaps

Need to keep it low-carb but high-flavor?

Use almond flour instead of regular flour in the batter.
Skip the beans and corn; stick with cheese, chicken, or even ground beef.
Serve with cauliflower rice or avocado salad instead of tortillas.

Even without the carbs, you’ll still enjoy every creamy, cheesy bite—guilt-free!

Frequently Asked Questions About Baked Chili Rellenos

Can you make baked chili rellenos ahead of time?

Absolutely! Baked chili rellenos are great for meal prep. You can roast, stuff, and assemble them a day ahead. Just cover the dish with foil and refrigerate. When you’re ready, pop them into the oven and bake as directed. You may need to add 5 extra minutes if they’re cold from the fridge.

Do you peel the peppers before stuffing them?

Yes, peeling is highly recommended—especially for Poblano or Anaheim peppers. After roasting, the skin becomes blistered and tough. Let them steam in a sealed bag or covered bowl, then peel under running water. This step makes your oven chili rellenos soft, smooth, and way more enjoyable to eat.

What is the best pepper to use for baked chile rellenos?

Poblano peppers are traditional and widely used for their rich flavor and mild heat. Anaheim peppers are a great milder option, especially for kids or those who prefer less spice. Want more heat? Try Hatch peppers. Not sure which to pick? This Hatch vs Anaheim Peppers guide breaks it down beautifully.

Can I use canned green chiles instead of fresh?

You can, but they won’t have the same depth of flavor. Canned chiles are convenient and great in a pinch, especially if you’re short on time. However, roasting fresh peppers adds a smoky sweetness that elevates the dish.

How do you make chili rellenos less spicy?

It’s all about the pepper! Choose Anaheim or Poblano for a mild experience. Also, skip adding cayenne or pepper jack cheese if you’re heat-sensitive. To cool things down, serve with sour cream or avocado crema.

What does the egg and flour mixture taste like when baked?

Great question! The baked batter has a light, fluffy, almost soufflé-like texture. It’s not crispy like the fried version, but it hugs the pepper beautifully and adds a creamy richness that complements the cheese.

Can I freeze baked chili rellenos?

Yes, but freeze them after baking, not raw. Let them cool completely, then wrap tightly in foil or place in an airtight container. Freeze for up to 2 months. To reheat, bake at 350°F straight from frozen for about 25–30 minutes.

How do I reheat them without drying them out?

To reheat baked chile rellenos, place them in an oven-safe dish, cover with foil, and bake at 325°F for about 15–20 minutes. Covering them locks in moisture so the filling stays creamy and the peppers don’t dry out.

Hungry for more? Visit our website for full recipes and follow us on Pinterest for daily foodie inspo you’ll love to pin!